Pelley Law Office LLP
Dallas Office
Plano Office
Sherman Office

No Charge For Initial Consultation ($250 value)

Menu Contact

Over 80 Years Of Combined Experience

View Our Practice Areas

Miranda Warnings and Custody When the Cop Takes Your Keys.

An appeals case out of Eastland entitled Steadman v. State involved Fifth Amendment concerns.  Allowing the officer to testify that the defendant neither admitted nor denied allegations against him was not a Fifth Amendment rights violation.  Also, it was not improper for the prosecutor to argue to the jury that the defendant did not deny the allegations against him.  "The law is somewhat unsettled in this area, but we do have some guidance."  Although the case involved post Miranda Warnings silence, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals has stated that 'pre-arrest silence is a constitutionally permissible area of inquiry'.  In another case, while the court found it unnecessary to address the question of the admissibility of pre-arrest silence, it did note that there were those federal courts of appeals that had held that pre-arrest silence is admissible.  It also noted that there were other federal courts of appeals in which the opposite result was reached.

The officer took the defendant's keys after he had admitted that he had a couple of beers that night, and it was held that he was not in custody.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Awards & Recognition

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Office Locations

Plano office
Sherman office
Dallas office

Plano Office
1312 14th Street, Suite 100
Plano, Texas 75074

Phone: 972-608-0335
Map & Directions

Sherman Office
905 North Travis Street
Sherman, Texas 75090

Phone: 903-813-4778
Map & Directions

Dallas Office
100 Crescent Court
Suite 700
Dallas, Texas 75201

Phone: 214-733-1775
Map & Directions